Home › Compare › Candy.AI vs Secrets.AI
⚡ QUICK ANSWER
Secrets.AI wins on features — a 4.9 vs 4.2 rating, video generation, 100+ roleplay scenarios, and full NSFW at $19.99/mo or $9.17/mo billed yearly (no tier upgrades). Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo monthly or $3.99/mo equivalent on an annual plan ($47.88/yr). Full NSFW on Candy.AI requires the $24.99/mo Premium tier. Best pick depends on your needs.
Candy.AI vs Secrets.AI (2026): Which Is Actually Better?
Candy.AI is one of the most recognizable names in AI companions — great mobile app, huge user base, easy onboarding. Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo on the monthly plan, or $3.99/mo equivalent if you pay $47.88 for a full year upfront — but full NSFW access requires the $24.99/mo Premium tier regardless of billing cycle. After testing both platforms for several weeks, Secrets.AI pulls ahead on features that matter to power users: video generation, 100+ scenarios, smarter memory, and full NSFW included at $19.99/mo ($9.17/mobilled yearly) without tier upgrades. Here's the honest breakdown.
Candy.AI
4.2 ★ (our rating) · $13.99/mo · $3.99/mo (annual)
Polished app, easy to start
Try Candy.AI Free →Secrets.AI
4.9 ★ (our rating) · From $9.17/mo (billed yearly)
More features, better value
Try Secrets.AI Free →Quick Verdict
Secrets.AI wins 4.9 vs 4.2 overall. Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo (monthly) or $3.99/mo equivalent on an annual plan ($47.88/yr) — but full NSFW access requires upgrading to the $24.99/mo Premium tier. Secrets.AI at $19.99/mo ($9.17/mo billed yearly) includes video generation, 100+ roleplay scenarios, and full NSFW without tier upgrades. Candy.AI is a solid beginner pick; Secrets.AI is the better value for power users.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Why Secrets.AI Wins
Video generationis the biggest differentiator. Candy.AI doesn't offer it on its base plan; Secrets.AI does. For users who want more than still images, this alone justifies the switch.
Roleplay depthis another gap. Secrets.AI ships with 100+ pre-built fantasy scenarios and a fully customizable persona engine. Candy.AI's scenario library is noticeably thinner — fine for casual chat, limiting for immersive roleplay.
Memoryis more advanced on Secrets.AI — it tracks preferences, past events, and relationship history in a way that makes conversations feel genuinely continuous. Candy.AI's memory works but feels more surface-level.
Price requires nuance. Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo on the monthly plan — less than Secrets.AI's $19.99/mo. Its annual plan ($47.88/yr) works out to $3.99/mo equivalent, which is cheaper than Secrets.AI's annual rate of $9.17/mo ($109.99/yr). However, Candy.AI's paid tier is still limited — full NSFW access only unlocks at the $24.99/mo Premium tier. Secrets.AI includes everything at $19.99/mo ($9.17/mo billed yearly): video generation, full NSFW, 100+ scenarios. For power users, Secrets.AI delivers better value per dollar once you account for what each plan actually unlocks.
Choose Candy.AI if…
- You're brand new to AI companions
- A polished, intuitive mobile app is a must
- You want the simplest onboarding flow
- Casual chat is enough — no deep roleplay
- You're not interested in video generation
Choose Secrets.AI if…
- You want video generation without add-ons
- Deep roleplay with 100+ scenarios matters
- You want NSFW access without jumping tiers
- Advanced memory & continuity are important
- You want the highest overall-rated platform
Our Recommendation: Secrets.AI
Candy.AI's annual plan ($3.99/mo equivalent) is cheaper than Secrets.AI long-term, but Secrets.AI is more feature-rich and rated higher. On monthly billing Candy.AI is also cheaper at $13.99/mo vs Secrets.AI's $19.99/mo. If you want video generation, full NSFW without tier upgrades, and deeper roleplay, Secrets.AI is the better choice.
18+ only · Affiliate links