Home › Compare › Candy.AI vs Secrets.AI
⚡ QUICK ANSWER
Secrets.AI wins on features — a 4.9 vs 4.2 rating, video generation, 100+ roleplay scenarios, and full NSFW at $19.99/mo or $9.17/mo billed yearly (no tier upgrades). Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo monthly or $3.99/mo equivalent on an annual plan ($47.88/yr). Full NSFW on Candy.AI is locked behind higher tiers. Best pick depends on your needs.
Candy.AI vs Secrets.AI (2026): Which Is Actually Better?
Candy.AI is one of the most recognizable names in AI companions — great mobile app, huge user base, easy onboarding. Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo on the monthly plan, or $3.99/mo equivalent if you pay $47.88 for a full year upfront — but full NSFW is locked behind higher tiers regardless of billing cycle. Comparing their published features and pricing, Secrets.AI pulls ahead on features that matter to power users: video generation, 100+ scenarios, an advanced memory system, and full NSFW included at $19.99/mo ($9.17/mo billed yearly) without tier upgrades. Here's the honest breakdown.
Candy.AI
4.2 ★ (our rating) · $13.99/mo · $3.99/mo (annual)
Polished app, easy to start
Try Candy.AI Free →Secrets.AI
4.9 ★ (our rating) · From $9.17/mo (billed yearly)
More features, better value
Try Secrets.AI Free →Quick Verdict
Secrets.AI wins 4.9 vs 4.2 overall. Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo (monthly) or $3.99/mo equivalent on an annual plan ($47.88/yr) — but full NSFW is locked behind higher tiers. Secrets.AI at $19.99/mo ($9.17/mo billed yearly) includes video generation, 100+ roleplay scenarios, and full NSFW without tier upgrades. Candy.AI is a solid beginner pick; Secrets.AI is the better value for power users.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Why Secrets.AI Wins
Video generation is the biggest differentiator. Candy.AI doesn't offer it on its base plan; Secrets.AI does. For users who want more than still images, this alone justifies the switch.
Roleplay depth is another gap. Secrets.AI ships with 100+ pre-built fantasy scenarios and a fully customizable persona engine. Candy.AI's scenario library is noticeably thinner — fine for casual chat, limiting for immersive roleplay.
Memory is closer than the marketing suggests. Secrets.AI publishes an advanced memory system built around preferences, past events and relationship history. On the combined Memory & Roleplay axis of our NSFW Score the two are near-level: Candy.AI 9.1/10, Secrets.AI 9.0/10.
Price requires nuance. Candy.AI costs $13.99/mo on the monthly plan — less than Secrets.AI's $19.99/mo. Its annual plan ($47.88/yr) works out to $3.99/mo equivalent, which is cheaper than Secrets.AI's annual rate of $9.17/mo ($109.99/yr). However, Candy.AI's paid tier is still limited — full NSFW is locked behind higher tiers. Secrets.AI's paid plan at $19.99/mo ($9.17/mo billed yearly) includes full NSFW and 100+ scenarios, plus video generation (token credits). For power users, compare what each plan unlocks, not just the entry price.
Choose Candy.AI if…
- You're brand new to AI companions
- A polished, intuitive mobile app is a must
- You want the simplest onboarding flow
- Casual chat is enough — no deep roleplay
- You're not interested in video generation
Choose Secrets.AI if…
- You want video generation without add-ons
- Deep roleplay with 100+ scenarios matters
- You want NSFW access without jumping tiers
- Advanced memory & continuity are important
- You want the highest overall-rated platform
Our Recommendation: Secrets.AI
Candy.AI's annual plan ($3.99/mo equivalent) is cheaper than Secrets.AI long-term, but Secrets.AI is more feature-rich and rated higher. On monthly billing Candy.AI is also cheaper at $13.99/mo vs Secrets.AI's $19.99/mo. If you want video generation, full NSFW without tier upgrades, and deeper roleplay, Secrets.AI is the better choice.
18+ only · Affiliate links